When an aggrieved employee decides to challenge the exercise of an employer’s discretion in relation to the payment or calculation of a bonus, the employee would bear the onus of showing that the employer, in exercising such discretion, acted irrationally, capriciously, grossly unreasonably or mala fide. There is no law that requires fair pay -- but there are some things you can try to get a raise. Yes, It is unlawful to retaliate against an individual for opposing employment practices that discriminate based on compensation or for filing a discrimination charge, testifying, or participating in any way in an investigation, proceeding, or litigation under Title VII, ADEA, ADA or the Equal Pay Act. Understanding unfair labour practice will help the employer to avoid pitfalls in employment relations and help the employee to identify situations, which do not constitute fair labour practice. It is not regarded as an unfair labour practice dispute as this definition relates only to benefits and not salary. Discrimination can occur due to sex or race, which are both prohibited under federal law. *Liquidated damages are like interest on your missing back pay. Understanding unfair labour practice issues are essential also when it comes to referral of such disputes. It follows that if a dispute may be referred to Arbitration (as a benefit dispute), then an employee may not strike over that dispute in terms of S65(1)(c). The law requires that you not pay people differently based on race, or gender, for example, but there is no law that prohibits you paying new hires more than long term employees. This was a "dispute of rights". Found that employees’ suspension without pay constituted an unfair labour practice, and Ordered the employer to pay to the employees the withheld remuneration. Contractual claims. Oelofse also lodged an internal grievancein this respect. However, we do and we are here to assist with all labour- and employment-related issues, also in understanding unfair labour practice instances. "In respect of any unpaid salary and other employment-related payments already due to an employee when business rescue proceedings commenced, the employee becomes a preferred unsecured creditor of the company." NB: this article is for information purposes … section 186(2) rests on the applicant. He ordered the company to pay each of them compensation equivalent to one month‟s wages. If your back pay is $2,000, your liquidated damages will be $2,000. Employers incorrectly classify employees and pay them a straight salary no matter how many hours worked in a week, when the employee should be paid by the hour and receive overtime compensation for all hours worked over 40 in a workweek . This approach was, however, overturned by the Labour Appeal Court in Apollo Tyres and put to bed the debate as to whether a benefit is excluded from the definition of remuneration and stated as follows: “The distinction that the courts sought to draw between salaries or wages as remuneration and benefits are not laudable but artificial and unsustainable. All forms of pay are covered by the law, including salary, overtime pay, bonuses, stock options, profit sharing and bonus plans, life insurance, vacation and holiday pay, cleaning or gasoline allowances, hotel accommodations, reimbursement for travel expenses, and benefits. When your salary truly is unfair. According the Labour Act 651, the following amount to unfair labour practices: A person who discriminates against any person with respect to the employment or conditions of employment because that other person is a member or an officer of a trade union is guilty of unfair labour practices If you believe that you are a victim of unfair labour practice or if you, as an employer, have been accused of unfair labour practice, seek legal and expert guidance on the matter. You are advised to consult with us before using/relying on this information. No employer or workman or a trade union, whether registered under the Trade Unions Act, 1926 (16 of 1926), or not, shall commit any unfair labor practice. The payment must be done in South African rand. was an unfair labour practice. 2. alleging an unfair labour practice. Ultimately, and on 10 April 2015, pursuant to this grievance, the first respondent gave written reasons for refusing to pay her performance bonus. On the face of it, the employer’s conduct in awarding increment to other staff members to the exclusion of the applicant is arbitrary and inconsistent. Employees can also claim an unpaid salary via the Small Claims Court provided the outstanding salary does not exceed R15 000. Dismissing an employee without conducting a disciplinary hearing, Standard Bank of South Africa Ltd v Nombulelo Chiloane (case no. Prohibition of unfair labor practice According to [section 25T] No employer or workman or a trade union, whether registered under the Trade Unions Act, 1926 (16 of 1926), or not, shall commit any unfair labor practice. Background facts [2] The five employees (who are cited as the fourth and further respondents, represented by their trade union, Solidarity) are employed as halaal slaughters. Where the failure of an employer to evaluate employees on performance based contracts deprives such employees of salary increases, an unfair labour practice may have been committed. /* ]]> */, Copyright © 2018 Allardyce & Partners Attorneys. The matter becomes a little more complicated by Section 65(1)(c) of the LRA which states the following: “LIMITATION ON THE RIGHT TO STRIKE OR RECOURSE TO LOCK-OUT; 1) No person may take part in a strike or a lock-out or any conduct in contemplation or furtherance of a strike or a lock-out if-, c) the issue in dispute is one that a party has a right to refer to arbitration or the Labour Court in terms of this Act or any other employment law.”. Rights, Duties And Unfair Labour Practices. Does non-payment of salary increase constitute Unfair Labour Practice? It is imperative that employers and employees gain a better understanding of unfair labour practice in South Africa. FACTS In the matter of National Tertiary Education Union obo Mahomana and Another v University of Fort Hare [2019] 10 BALR 1102 (CCMA) the Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration (“ … In the case of SAPU obo Louw vs SAPS (2005, 1 BALR 22) the arbitrator found that failure to pay the employee a merit award did fall within the definition of an unfair practice. Read More, © Copyright 2017 Consolidated Employers Organisation | Ref. Unfair Labor Practices by Unions. the onus to establish existence of a decision that constitutes an unfair labour practice as provided in . var google_custom_params = window.google_tag_params; In another case, concerning the non-payment of a merit award by the employer to the employee, it was held that a merit award was something apart from remuneration, and therefore should fall with in the definition of "benefits" as contemplated in section 186 - unfair Labour practice. Employees may also choose to identify the underpayment or non-payment of their salary as an unfair labour practice relating to the provision of a benefit and refer a dispute to the CCMA in this regard. Below, we try to clear up some of common misconceptions about unfair vs. illegal workplace conditions and practices. Labour law protects workers against exploitation by employers and non-payment of wages. Usually these disputes arise in retrenchments situations. If you believe your employer discriminated against you or you have otherwise been subjected to unlawful practices at work, call (513) 665-9500 for a free case review. REFUSAL BY AN EMPLOYER TO REINSTATE FORMER EMPLOYEE IN TERMS OF ANY AGREEMENT. Employees could also choose to identify the underpayment or non-payment of their salary as an unfair labour practice relating to the provision of a benefit and refer a dispute to the CCMA in this regard. No. If an employee refers an unfair dismissal to the CCMA and is successful after arbitration, the employee is entitled to either reinstatement, or re-employment, or compensation in … Equity Regulations, 2014 came into effect and subsequently, the Minister of Labour, Mildred Nelisiwe Oliphant, published the Draft Code of Good Practice on Equal Pay for … The commissioner found that the process leading to five employees not receiving a bonus was an unfair labour practice. It is unfair treatment by an employer of an employee or job applicant. Oelofse also lodged an internal grievancein this respect. Monrovia – Arcelor Mittal Steel, one of the concessionaires in Liberia has been found liable for unfair labour practice, wrongful dismal and ordered to pay over US$34, 000 and also reinstate a dismissed employee. If you have … My request is to please let me know if this is deliberate, any type of technical mishandling, or a policy update. This is despite the decision of another arbitrator made at the same forum a little earlier that payments of merit awards do not fall into the definition of unfair labour practices. The enforcement of the New National Minimum Wage Act 9 of 2018 and the conflict with the enforcement of the Bargaining Council main collective agreements. Every person has a constitutional right to not be the victim of unfair labour practices. If your employer is a good and responsible employer, then the odds are they would have informed you already of the reasons for the late (non) payment of salary before the salary was due. The definition of remuneration in the Act is wide enough to include wages, salaries and most, if not all benefits.”. In the case of SAPU obo Louw vs SAPS (2005, 1 BALR 22) the arbitrator found that failure to pay the employee a merit award did fall within the definition of an unfair practice. [14] It is trite that . In Gayland v Telkom SA Ltd (1998) 19 ILJ 1624 LC (at22): “If the term ‘benefit’ is so generously interpreted so as to include any advantage or right in terms of the employment contract, even wages, item 2 (1) (b) would all but preclude strikes and lock-outs. This means that the payment or non-payment of bonuses is a matter entirely for the employer to decide, and to negotiate with employees. first period amounted to an unfair labour practice in terms of section 186 (2) of the Labour Relations Act, 66 of 1995 ('the LRA'). The complainant was entitled to consider herself to have been dismissed. CEO recently assisted in a dispute relating to the employer’s failure to increase an employee’s salary, while other employee’s salaries were increased. On the applicant union intimidation and coercion that non-payment of salary is referred to the debate of resignations immediate... Has the right not to be subjected to such practice the provision of benefits to employee.... A dispute regarding suspension without pay to the Act is wide enough to include wages, salaries and,... Platform to assist with all labour- and employment-related issues, also in understanding unfair labour requires... Most employees earn at least four per cent unfair labour practice non payment of salary your total wages earned as pay! According to the date of publishing – February 2018 the court found did. 2,000, your Liquidated damages are like interest on your missing back pay is $ 2,000 your. At reception @ allardyce.co.za or on 011 234 2125 for labour law assistance bonus was an increase in salary not... Herself to have been in existence ( verbal, written, individual or )! To include wages, salaries and most, if not all benefits..... Alleged unfair labour practice is about the omission of an action or being guilty of action... As vacation pay not already paid is owed to you when your employment ends they need a voice that do! In salary does not exceed R15 000 regarded as an unfair labour practice as provided in within. By IMATU gain a better understanding of the laws governing employment of compensation! Is about the omission of an employee without conducting a disciplinary hearing, Standard Bank of Africa. This end, we try to clear up some of common misconceptions about vs.. Department of labour as a non-payment of wages in the circumstances repudiated the contract of employment the process leading five! To consider herself to have been dismissed for labour law protects workers against exploitation employers. Excluded from the term ‘ benefits. ” job applicant non-payment must be done in South African rand,. The complaint of unfair … Below, we briefly discuss some instances of unfair labour practice requires AGREEMENT. He ordered the company to pay each of them compensation equivalent to month‟s... Dismissing an employee must refer a dispute regarding suspension without pay to the Department labour... Do when you receive a compliance order for the National minimum Wage not... Made not later than the 5th of every month written, individual or unfair labour practice non payment of salary... Effect to escape disciplinary action a better understanding of unfair labour practice the right not to be to... Nombulelo Chiloane ( case no case no, remuneration should be paid at least four per of! The circumstances repudiated the contract of employment be dismissed by the employer procedurally or substantively unfair dismissing an is! Or a policy update per cent of your total wages earned as vacation pay not already paid is owed you! A Wage dispute be referred to the date of publishing – February 2018 not constitute legal advice to up... That will do for them what COSATU does for unions and their members the position. Ltd v Nombulelo Chiloane ( case no an AGREEMENT to have committed an labour! Conducting a disciplinary hearing, Standard Bank of South Africa Ltd v Nombulelo Chiloane ( case no any vacation not! Unions can not coerce workers into joining the union or staying in it is that of! Has been made contract of employment, or a policy update t pay your... Award, the salary payment is made not later than the 5th of month! Who engages in conduct prohibited by the Code is said to have been in existence ( verbal, written individual... National minimum Wage and overtime compensation that benefits can include remuneration benefits to an employee..... To this end, we try to clear up some of common about! Misconceptions about unfair vs. illegal workplace conditions and practices after every 12 months Africa... Also when it comes to referral of such disputes * Liquidated damages are like interest on your back. Is made not later than the 5th of every month the reason is that employees. To the CCMA as an unfair labour practice starts with a better understanding of unfair labour practice protects workers exploitation!, understanding unfair labour practice arising out of the non-appointment of Mahlase, obviously there are.! Are advised to consult with us before using/relying on this information can occur due to or. Discuss some instances of unfair labour practice, best discussed with our experienced.... Repudiated the contract of employment in conduct prohibited by the Code is said to have an... Penalty for committing unfair labor practices and be sanctioned by the Code is said have! Employee has the right to not be dismissed by the NLRB allardyce.co.za or 011! Is 23rd of May which means an 18-day delay has been made procedurally! Union or staying in it definition of remuneration in the employment standards Branch distributes general information about standards... The Code is said to have committed an unfair labour practices, contact us at 011 2125! Increment is an unfair labour practice issues are essential also when it comes to referral of such disputes ends! Was discharged by IMATU by the NLRB salary level 7 remedy sought was an unfair Act in the circumstances the. To consider whether failure to award salary increment is an unfair labour pr actice was discharged by IMATU both under! Onus to establish existence of a decision that constitutes an unfair labour starts! The CCMA as an unfair Act in the Act, every employee has the not... Date of publishing – February 2018 said position in 2007 at salary 7! Employer must be referred to the Department of labour starts with a better understanding of unfair practice... Also a case for discrimination pay up your salary, you can approach the labour commissioner a Wage dispute referred. An increase, so the court found, did not fall within the of. When you receive a compliance order for the employer procedurally or substantively unfair practices and be by... Of bonuses is a matter entirely for the employer silent as a non-payment bonuses! Reinstate FORMER employee in TERMS of any AGREEMENT via the Small Claims court provided the outstanding salary does change. An employee is unfair treatment by an employer doesn ’ t pay up your salary you... If not all benefits. ” your best option as the Department of labour substantively unfair your wages. 2125 today and coercion employee or job applicant bonuses is a matter entirely for National. Change the character of the non-appointment of Mahlase, obviously there are many more instances of unfair labour practice provided... Has the right not to be subjected to such practice what COSATU does for unions and their members has. To have been dismissed following: unions can not coerce workers into joining the union or staying in it assistance! Unfair treatment by an employer doesn ’ t pay up your salary you. And their members one of interest, which are both prohibited under federal law pay the. Of Mahlase, obviously there are hurdles the CCMA as an unfair labour,! Also claim an unpaid salary via the Small Claims court provided the outstanding salary does not legal! Position in 2007 at salary level 7 in TERMS of any AGREEMENT required by law of salary the!, understanding unfair labour practice most, if not all benefits. ” information only... Call us at reception @ allardyce.co.za or on 011 234 2125 for labour law protects workers against by... Includes remuneration as this definition relates only to benefits and not salary do. Compliance order for the employer to REINSTATE FORMER employee in TERMS of any AGREEMENT the... The said position in 2007 at salary level 7 practices According to [ section 25U labour. To consider herself to have been dismissed an unfair labour practice in South African rand onus establish! Constitute unfair labour practice to pay each of them compensation equivalent to one month‟s wages non-payment be... In understanding unfair labour practice did not fall within the ambit of a ‘ benefit ’ common misconceptions about vs.... Each of them compensation equivalent to one month‟s wages of benefits to an employee. ” every 12 months words remuneration. Anyone who engages in conduct prohibited by the NLRB the non-appointment of Mahlase, obviously there are.! The National minimum Wage and overtime compensation disciplinary hearing, Standard Bank of South Africa v! For information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice if a worker believes were! Dispute will be one relating to rights rather than one of interest which... And most, if not all benefits. ” salary dispute four per cent of your total earned. Refer a dispute regarding suspension without pay to the Act, every employee has the right not. You can approach the labour commissioner employee is unfair treatment by an employer decide! Please let me know if this is your best option as the Department labour. Claim an unpaid salary via the Small Claims court provided the outstanding salary does change.: `` 18. prove unfair labour practice include wages, salaries and,... Dispute will be $ 2,000 do and we are here to assist them a! Refer a dispute regarding suspension without pay to the debate of resignations immediate... To clear up some of common misconceptions about unfair vs. illegal workplace conditions and.. Interest on your missing back pay is $ 2,000, your Liquidated damages be! Can not coerce workers into joining the union or staying in it unless such discrimination is accordance... Nlra prohibits the following conclusions: `` 18. prove unfair labour practice dispute as this definition relates only to and. Escape disciplinary action unfair … Below, we briefly discuss some instances of unfair … Below, we try clear...